The three families: comtoise, mantel clock and carriage clock

The comtoise, also called a Morbier clock, is a weight-driven long-case clock made in the Franche-Comté region from the eighteenth century into the early twentieth. The movement has a pressed-brass front plate, an enamel dial and a long pendulum, often a decorative pressed-brass one. Many comtoise movements are sold without their tall case and hung on a wall bracket; a full case stands roughly 90 to 100 in (230 to 250 cm) and needs a ceiling to match.

The mantel clock, or pendule, is spring-driven and sits on a chimney piece or a console table. Cases range from gilt bronze and porcelain to black slate and marble; the marble clocks are heavy, often over 30 lb (14 kg), and were sold with a pair of matching urns or candelabras called a garniture. A round movement signed by a Paris maker is common; the signature identifies the movement maker, not necessarily the case maker.

The carriage clock is a small brass clock with glass panels and a carrying handle, made in large numbers from the mid-nineteenth century. It runs on a platform escapement and usually needs winding every eight days. A carriage clock suits a bedside table or a desk; a comtoise suits an entryway with height; a mantel clock belongs in the living room.

Movements, winding and servicing

A mechanical French clock needs cleaning and fresh oil every three to five years from a clockmaker. Old oil turns to varnish, pivots wear and a neglected movement can be expensive to repair. Never oil a movement yourself and never force a key. Ask the seller whether the clock has been serviced and whether it runs for a full week on one winding.

A comtoise strikes the hour and, on most examples, repeats the strike about two minutes later. The weights are heavy, several kilograms each, and the cords or chains must be checked for wear. A mantel clock may have a bell or a gong; a cracked bell changes the sound. A carriage clock should have both its key and its original handle; replaced glass panels are common and acceptable if stated.

Transport is where damage happens. Remove the pendulum, tie or remove the weights and keep the key with the clock. Marble cases chip at the corners; wrap them separately. On arrival, set the clock on a level surface and let it settle before regulating. A clock that stops on a tilted mantel is not broken, only out of beat.

Running or stopped: displaying a French clock honestly

A clock bought for its case can stay stopped. Say so in the description if you sell it later, and set the hands to a pleasing position rather than leaving them at the hour the movement failed. A stopped comtoise movement hung on the wall of a kitchen is a legitimate decorative choice; a running one in the same place will be heard across the house.

Care of the case follows the material. Gilt bronze should be dusted with a soft brush and never polished, because polish removes the gilding. Black marble can be wiped with a barely damp cloth; acids, including vinegar, etch it. Enamel dials crack with heat and should not be cleaned with anything but a dry cloth.

For placement, keep a mantel clock away from direct heat from the fire, which dries the oil and warps veneers. Center it on the chimney piece and balance it with the pair of candlesticks or urns it may have been sold with. Our French clocks category and the French country living room page show how a clock sits among other pieces.

What to compare

FormSuggested UseDecisive Check
Comtoise long-case or wall movementEntryway or kitchen with ceiling heightWeights, cords and the strike sequence
Mantel clock, gilt or marbleChimney piece or console in the living roomCase chips and a serviced movement
Brass carriage clockBedside, desk, small shelvesKey, handle, glass panels and platform escapement

Your buying checklist

Continue planning your room

Frequently asked questions

How often does a French clock need servicing?

A mechanical movement needs cleaning and fresh oil every three to five years from a clockmaker. Old oil hardens and pivots wear, so a neglected clock costs more to repair later. Ask the seller for the date of the last service and whether the clock runs a full week on one winding before buying.

What is a comtoise clock?

A comtoise, or Morbier, is a weight-driven long-case clock made in the Franche-Comté region of eastern France from the eighteenth century onward. It has a pressed-brass front, an enamel dial and a long pendulum. Many movements are sold without the tall case and hung on a wall bracket, which suits rooms with ordinary ceilings.

Can I keep an antique French clock as decoration without running it?

Yes. A clock chosen for its case can stay stopped, and many people prefer the silence. Set the hands to a pleasing position, keep the key and pendulum with the clock, and state that it is not running if you sell it. A stopped clock still needs a dry room and protection from direct heat.

How do I move a mantel clock or comtoise safely?

Remove the pendulum, remove or tie the weights of a comtoise, and keep the key in a labeled bag. Wrap marble cases separately because corners chip. On arrival, place the clock on a level surface, rehang the pendulum and let it settle before adjusting the rate. A clock that stops on a tilted shelf is simply out of beat.

Sources & further reading